A Comparison Chart

CategoryMy MetaphysicsEvangelical ChristianityKen WilberDawkins‑Style Humanism
1. OntologyOne reality, three resolutions.God–creation dualism.Nondual Spirit.Materialism only.
2. Ultimate RealityAbsolute as depth, not a being.Personal God.Spirit as consciousness.No ultimate reality.
3. StructureArchetypes as real constraints.Created order.Developmental structures.No archetypes.
4. CosmologyDynamic emergence.Linear salvation history.Evolution toward Spirit.Scientific cosmology only.
5. PersonSelf as process/recursion.Immortal soul.Evolving self.Biological organism.
6. Higher SelfA relation, not a being.Holy Spirit/conscience.Higher developmental stage.No Higher Self.
7. SacredWhole seen in the part.God’s presence.Spirit recognising itself.No sacred realm.
8. LoveStructural across levels.God is love.Eros + Agape.Evolved bonding emotion.
9. EthicsCoherence + presence.Divine command.Higher‑stage action.Human wellbeing.
10. SufferingCost of finitude.Result of sin/testing.Growth catalyst.Natural fact.
11. EvilBreakdown of coherence.Rebellion/demonic.Lower structures.Harmful behaviour.
12. AfterlifePattern persists; recursion ends.Heaven/hell.Reincarnation/evolution.No afterlife.
13. SalvationAlignment with the whole.Atonement.Awakening.No salvation concept.
14. PracticeIncrease coherence/presence.Prayer/scripture.Meditation/integral work.Inquiry and ethics.
15. AuthorityStructure of the Real.Bible/God’s will.Developmental models.Evidence and reason.
16. KnowledgeAlignment with Logos.Revelation + reason.Integrative knowing.Empirical science.
17. DeityPersonal deity as phenomenology.Literal personal God.Transpersonal Spirit.No deity.
18. FreedomPresence within coherence.Free will under God.Grows with development.Autonomy within biology.
19. PurposeNo teleology; emergent direction.God’s plan.Evolution toward Spirit.No cosmic purpose.
20. ReligionArchetypal expressions.Christianity uniquely true.All partial truths.

Discover more from Hearth and Heart Magazine

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Comments

Leave a comment