I grew up in a conservative Plymouth Brethren environment. More than that, I had one of the most hard-core evangelical childhood experiences: I was the preacher’s son and the pastor’s kid.
When I finally emerged from evangelicalism it felt as though I’d been locked in a cultural cupboard under the stairs. But thinking about it, a cupboard is small, dusty and disappointing. Perhaps I should have alluded to a different children’s story and a special wardrobe.
Evangelical Narnia is rather more attractive.
The thing is, I’ve recently started using the term Evangelical Narnia as a kind of private joke.
Please don’t read this entirely negatively. In fact, that’s the point.
It’s not the case that everyone wants to leave Narnia because it’s awful. In fact Narnia can be quite wonderful.
That’s why people stay.
It is a complete world with its own internally consistent logic. It contains stories, heroes, villains, certainty, meaning and a reassuring explanation for almost everything. Most importantly, it contains a clear distinction between what is inside this world and what is outside.
Inside is where the truth is.
Outside is where people are mistaken.
At least, that is the theory.
The University Problem
People often imagine that university destroys faith through clever lecturers spouting militant atheism. Apart from one Philosophy of Religion lecturer, that wasn’t really my experience. Even the study of other religions didn’t drown my naïve faith in a sea of newfound relativism.
University did not challenge my faith directly. The Christian Union saw to that. Our friendly holy huddle had Bible studies, worship meetings and was ready with enough apologetic arguments to repel a small invasion. It was a mini Evangelical Narnia all of its own.
Reality, however, proved considerably more difficult to defend against.
The real problem was encountering actual people in that outside world.
Among them was an atheist girl.
But this is not a simple “met a girl, lost my faith” story. My certainty was already wobbling, and the implications would take another decade to work themselves out.
But she did present a problem.
Not because she won arguments.
Because she stubbornly refused to fit the category.
She was supposed to be an unbeliever.
Instead she appeared to be a human being.
This was unexpectedly inconvenient.
It is surprisingly difficult to gaze lovingly into somebody’s eyes whilst simultaneously regarding them as doomed to a ‘lost eternity’ and as an evangelistic target.
As a foundation for a healthy relationship, this is not ideal.
Reality Overload
The crisis that really destabilized me as a young student was not simply theological.
It was existential.
The best description I have for it now is reality overload.
For years I had been raised within a tightly integrated symbolic world. Then I stepped outside it and discovered that reality was larger than advertised.
Much larger.
More complicated.
And morally far less clear-cut:
Good atheists.
Wise unbelievers.
Different kinds of relationships that were genuinely loving
Even other ways to find meaning and purpose in life.
Entire worlds that existed perfectly happily without asking Evangelical Narnia for permission.
The Virtues of Narnia
Human beings seem to have an incurable tendency to create Narnias.
We gather with those who have similar beliefs and so tend to reinforce our own. Within the group mind everything makes sense, and even the implausible suddenly becomes believable. More than just creating an echo chamber we create the ultimate ‘safe space’ – even if we don’t call it that. This is a social and intellectual pocket reality in which to dwell undisturbed with the like minded. In this way we are separated from what would otherwise be problematic and challenging for our world view.
But sometimes, in order to sustain this world, we construct fortified intellectual borders and appoint earnest gatekeepers to maintain doctrinal purity.
In my experience Religious and Political sects are not that dissimilar in this regard.
The real trouble starts when we have to leave Narnia or deconstruct it because the greater reality has come crashing in.
However in escaping one plausibility structure, there is often a great temptation to construct another.
Conservative Narnia
Perhaps all my life I’ve been unconsciously trying to replace Evangelical Narnia 1.0 with a succession of new versions both secular and religious.
After university and evangelicalism I was very much on the political Left for many years and quite activist. However after another intellectual journey I now embrace a different kind of politics. Whether the Left left me or I left it is for another discussion. Safe to say that now and again I catch myself in a conservative political Narnia or trying to construct one.
Well, at least I now recognize where I am.
The interesting thing is that all the arguments which eventually undermined Evangelical Narnia also apply to Conservative Narnia. And Socialist Narnia, Progressive Narnia , Free Market Narnia, and Nationalist Narnia.
The world beyond the walls is never as simple as the people inside imagine.
The outsiders are not (all) barbarians out to get us.
The insiders are not always saints.
Reality remains stubbornly untidy – but I think I’ve finally made my peace with that.

Leave a Reply